Humint Events Online: Wanker of the Week: DNI Director Mike McConnell

Monday, January 14, 2008

Wanker of the Week: DNI Director Mike McConnell

"You know what waterboarding is?" [McConnell] asked. "You lay somebody on this table, or put them in an inclined position, and put a washcloth over their face, and you just drip water right here" -- he pointed to his nostrils. "Try it! What happens is, water will go up your nose. And so you will get the sensation of potentially drowning. That's all waterboarding is."

I asked if he considered that torture.

McConnell refused to answer directly, but he said, "My own definition of torture is something that would cause excruciating pain."

Did waterboarding fit that description?

Referring to his teen-age days as a lifeguard, he said, "I know one thing. I'm a water-safety instructor, but I cannot swim without covering my nose. I don't know if it's some deviated septum or mucus membrane, but water just rushes in." For him, he said, "waterboarding would be excruciating. If I had water draining into my nose, oh God, I just can't imagine how painful! Whether it's torture by anybody else's definition, for me it would be torture."

I queried McConnell again, later, about his views on waterboarding, since this exchange seemed to suggest that he personally condemned it. He rejected that interpretation. "You can do waterboarding lots of different ways," he said. "I assume you can get to the point that a person is actually drowning." That would certainly be torture, he said. The definition didn't seem very different from John Yoo's. The reason that he couldn't be more specific, McConnell said, is that "if it ever is determined to be torture, there will be a huge penalty to be paid for anyone engaging in it."
The AP's headline gives the impression that McConnell condemned waterboarding. He didn't. He's saying that if you have a deviated septum, then waterboarding is torture -- because it just feels like you're drowning. If not (and the interrogator doesn't go overboard), then apparently it's a-ok. It seems to be an easy distinction for him. The subtlety might be lost on others.


This Yahoo/Reuters article at least sees the distinction:
Waterboarding would be torture to me: U.S. spy chief
By Deborah Zabarenko
Sun Jan 13, 3:51 PM ET
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - U.S. intelligence chief Mike McConnell said in a magazine interview that waterboarding would be torture if it was used against him personally, but stopped short of condemning the controversial interrogation technique.

3 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

What happens is, water will go up your nose. And so you will get the sensation of potentially drowning. That's all waterboarding is.

wow is that all waterboarding is?
"hey bartender...waterboards all around!"

2:15 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

What does it say about a country whose leaders (sic) advocate and use waterboarding to tortue people into making false confessions?

Do your co-workers, neighbors, and friends get beyond the BS of saying "well, if doing it would save the life of even one person, then we have to be able to do it in that situation - besides you KNOW the terrusts and other Islamofascistswouldn't think twice about it, so why should WE".

4:59 PM  
Anonymous comprar puertas metalicas said...

No doubt, the chap is totally fair.

5:52 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home

Powered by Blogger